TL;DR
Get cleaning gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
A Hey Der Folks YouTube creator tested the $200 All American Sharpener Model 5005 Gen 2 and sharpened three zero-turn mower blades with it. He found the angle-guiding tool quick and consistent, but said it could take a while to recoup the cost; the value depends on how often a buyer sharpens blades.
A creator behind the Hey Der Folks YouTube channel used the $200 All American Sharpener Model 5005 Gen 2 to sharpen three blades from a zero-turn mower, reporting that the tool made the work quick and consistent. The test offers a first-hand look at an expensive sharpening jig, but does not establish that its cost is worthwhile for homeowners who sharpen blades infrequently.
The Model 5005 Gen 2 is a bench-mounted guide, not a complete sharpening system: buyers also need an angle grinder, which is not included. An adjustable grip holds the mower blade, while a guide arm moves the grinder along the blade’s bevel. The angle can be set from 15 to 45 degrees.
For the test, the creator attached the sharpener to a scrap piece of 2-by-4 lumber and clamped it to a workbench. With the angle set to 35 degrees, he said three strokes produced a noticeably clearer edge. He sharpened three blades for a zero-turn mower, though the source does not provide measurements of sharpness, cutting performance or time saved against another method.
The report also cites Bob Vila’s review of the same model. Its testers reportedly took about 10 minutes to assemble the unit and rated it their most consistent performer among eight sharpeners tested. They gave it full marks for ease of use, efficiency and quality, while its value score was lower, at 4.3 out of 5.
Who Benefits From the $200 Jig
The test highlights a trade-off between repeatability and price. By guiding the angle grinder, the jig is designed to reduce the guesswork involved in sharpening a blade freehand. That may appeal to people who maintain several blades or sharpen them often, including professional landscapers who need equipment ready for work.
For a homeowner with one push mower, the purchase is harder to justify. The test creator owned six blades—three on his mower and three spares—and still said the tool would take time to pay for itself through avoided professional sharpening costs. The source gives no price comparison for local sharpening services, so it cannot establish how many uses would recover the purchase price.
Lower-cost options include files, manual sharpeners, drill-powered sharpeners and other guide-arm tools. Those alternatives may cost less, but the source does not report side-by-side results for them in the creator’s test. The main takeaway is that the tool’s reported consistency does not automatically make it the best-value choice for every mower owner.
Products Worth Considering
Hisense 43-Inch E6SR Series Hi-QLED 4K UHD Smart Roku TV (2026 Model)
Arlo Pro Wireless Security Camera, 2K HDR, 6th Gen, 4-Camera Kit
Hisense 40-Inch Class QD4SR Series Hi-QLED FHD Smart Roku TV (2026 Model)
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Sharpener Guides Grinding
The All American Sharpener works with an angle grinder supplied by the user. Its grip secures the blade, and the guide arm controls the grinder’s movement along the cutting bevel. The adjustable angle lets the user set the guide for different blades, while the bench mounting provides a fixed base.
The creator’s test was a first-time use of this system, according to Hunker’s account. He mounted it to a workbench using a clamped scrap board rather than reporting a permanent installation. The cited Bob Vila review supplies a separate comparison across eight sharpeners, but the source does not provide the full testing protocol or the scores of every competing product.
““I never had it bog down, it never unexpectedly changed my angle … just very smooth consistently.””
— Hey Der Folks YouTube creator, as quoted by Hunker
What the Test Does Not Establish
The reported trial covered three blades and one user’s experience. It does not show how the tool performs over long-term use, whether the sharpened blades cut better in measured lawn tests, or how results compare directly with a file, a freehand grinder or lower-priced guides. The source also does not state when the video test took place.
The creator’s payback estimate is not supported by a stated local sharpening price, usage frequency or maintenance cost. Nor does the report give a detailed safety assessment. Bob Vila’s cited scores are reported by Hunker, but the available material does not include the full review methodology or individual results for all eight sharpeners.
Choosing a Sharpening Method
No follow-up test or product change is announced in the source material. For prospective buyers, the next step is to compare the jig’s current price and required angle grinder with the cost of professional sharpening and less expensive tools, using their own blade count and sharpening frequency.
The reported test supports a limited conclusion: the user found the jig straightforward and consistent for three blades. Whether that performance justifies $200 for a particular buyer remains a personal cost calculation, not a result the test settles.
Key Questions
What happened when the $200 sharpener was tested?
The Hey Der Folks creator used the All American Sharpener Model 5005 Gen 2 to sharpen three zero-turn mower blades. He said three strokes at a 35-degree setting made a clearer edge and described the grinder arm as smooth and consistent.
Does the All American Sharpener include an angle grinder?
No. It is a guide and blade-holding jig; the angle grinder must be supplied separately. Its guide angle is adjustable from 15 to 45 degrees.
Is the tool worth $200 for a homeowner?
The report does not give a universal answer. The creator said it could pay for itself over time, but that recovery would take a while. People who sharpen frequently or maintain several blades may have a stronger case than owners of a single-blade mower who sharpen only occasionally.
How did Bob Vila rate the sharpener?
Hunker reports that Bob Vila’s testers rated it their most consistent performer among eight sharpeners and gave it full marks for ease of use, efficiency and quality. Its value score was 4.3 out of 5.
Source: hunker.com
